Key Stops For The Best Burgers In Nashville And Franklin

Dated: 09/19/2014

Views: 3813

by TJ Anderson

News started floating around this week that Brentwood is getting a new craft beer and burgers stop, Murff's Craft Beers & Burgers, this fall, at 5015 Harpeth Drive. Many red-blooded Middle Tennessee men and women rejoice at news like this (during football season, so much the better), and it got me thinking about where I’d send a burger-loving out-of-towner for a solid picture of our local burger fare. (Which has, incidentally, only been getting better and better.)

Here are a few of my go-to local burger picks, around Davidson County and Williamson County. If you’re a local, you’ll certainly find these familiar (and that surely won’t stop you from having a passionate opinion about which makes the best burgers):

Gabby's Burgers & Fries 

493 Humphreys St.

Neighborhood: Downtown
The Basics: totally unassuming setting, totally remarkable burgers — these are grass-fed, super juicy and flavorful burgers that’d easily cost you 50 percent more in a fancy setting. 
Don't Forget to Order: the Gabby Burger, timeless and delicious, with two patties and generous American cheese. (Can’t hurt to grab a milkshake with house-made syrups either.)

The Pharmacy Burger Parlor & Beer Garden 

731 Mcferrin Ave.

Neighborhood: East Nashville
The Basics: a great Eastside place to pair craft beers (or house-made phosphate sodas for the teetotalers) with creative burgers made with local beef and local buns (from Provence). Extra bonus for folks who like to eat and drink al fresco — their outdoor space is ample and enjoyable.
Don’t Forget to Order: the Farm Burger, topped with applewood-smoked bacon, country ham, an over-easy egg and maple mustard. And pace yourself.

Riverside Grillshack

1000 Riverside Dr.

Neighborhood: East Nashville
The Basics: it’s not just a clever name — this is indeed a tiny shack along Riverside Dr., and it bears out the wide belief that humble settings often produce the best food. This place grew out of the Über-Tüber Hand Cut Fries food truck, and the crispy fries are well worth a nod, but the burgers — grass-fed local beef, of course — are more than enough to draw you in.
Don’t Forget to Order: straight-up Grillshack Burger, served with muenster cheese on a grilled Provence roll alongside some of those exemplary Über-Tüber fries.

Burger Up

2901 12th Ave. S in Nashville, 401 Cool Springs Blvd. in Franklin

Neighborhoods: 12 South and Cool Springs
The Basics: stylish and upscale restaurant (they have kale salad) serving top-notch burgers, from the familiar (mushroom swiss) to the more specialized (lamb with boursin cheese and honey mint dijon aioli).
Don’t Forget to Order: the perfectly smokey and sweet Woodstock burger, with Benton’s bacon, white cheddar and Jack Daniel’s maple ketchup.


2413 Elliston Pl.

Neighborhood: West Nashville, Belmont/Vanderbilt area
The Basics: Rotier’s is to Nashville burgers what Prince’s is to Nashville hot chicken, which is to say that it’s the OG against which newcomers are judged, and a standby longtime Nashvillians will always swear by. It’s been family-owned and operated since 1945, and their burgers are inexpensive and delicious. 
Don’t Forget to Order: the cheeseburger on French bread, a long-loved Nashvillian rite of passage.

Burger Republic 

420 11th Ave. S and 6900 Lenox Village Dr. Ste 22

Neighborhoods: The Gulch and Lenox Village
The Basics: a relative newcomer with a distinct burger focus, Burger Republic opened its first location in 2012, and riding the burger love for that location, expanded to The Gulch in 2014. They use certified Angus beef and default to a fluffy and delicious brioche bun for a bunch of crafty burger twists (like a Taco Truck burger with all the expected spices and fixins that name implies, and a Jalapeño Popper Burger with spicy buffalo sauce and tempura fried jalapeños).
Don’t Forget to Order: can’t go wrong with The Tennessee (with maple-glazed Benton’s bacon, Jack Daniel’s honey BBQ sauce, smoked ketchup, crispy onions and American cheese), which was praised in Zagat’s 50 States, 50 Burgers rundown. 

Those should be more than enough to introduce a visitor or Nashville newcomer to our town’s burger riches. But what do you think, locals — did I miss a key stop or two?

If you’ve checked out any of these places and fallen in love with the neighborhood, I’d love to show you around more and show you what’s on the market. Just drop a line.
Blog author image

TJ Anderson

TJ Anderson is a Nashville Realtor with Benchmark Realty who's helped countless clients both buy a home and sell a home in Nashville, Tennessee. He blogs about Nashville regularly, from Nashville-area....

Latest Blog Posts

Where To Order Catfish In Nashville

by TJ AndersonIf you follow me on Instagram, this is probably already clear to you, but I’m a diehard, devoted, dedicated Nashville Preds fan, and while we’re in the middle of the 2018 Stanley

Read More

Get Inspired By A Historic Nashville Bungalow Owned By A Young Nashville Star

by TJ AndersonLennon Stella's home, photo via People.comI was already impressed by Lennon Stella, who, by starring in TV drama Nashville, managed to build a double-threat career as an actress and

Read More

Nashville History Lesson On Pioneer John Donelson

By TJ AndersonWay back in the winter of 1779, while he was fighting the cold waters of the Cumberland alongside a hundred or so other early Middle Tennessee settlers, one figures John Donelson never

Read More

Stunning Luxury Home For Sale In Franklin Subdivision Hurstbourne Park

by TJ AndersonIf you’re looking to buy a home in Williamson County that gives you space for your family, room to entertain, lots of luxury and easy access to all that makes the area appealing: Let

Read More