Where To Find A Decent Bagel In Nashville

Dated: 01/18/2016

Views: 3365

by TJ Anderson

There are a lot of things we do in Nashville that no one can touch. Hot Chicken. Biscuits. Bonuts. But up until relatively recently, there were a good couple of things that we… let’s say had a little room to grow on. Flash back 10 years, and any New York transplant would’ve quickly rattled off two of them: pizza, and bagels.

We’ve made huge pizza strides over the past few years, with places like Five Points Pizza and DeSano Pizza Bakery. Last week we made another big bagel step forward as Proper Bagel opened its doors in Belmont, serving (fittingly) proper kettle-boiled and scratch-made bagels and bialys, flying in smoked salmon from Brooklyn and the like. 

Indication of how much old-school bagel makery is appreciated here: by day four, Proper Bagel had a line out the door for seven hours straight.

If you, too, are particular about a well-made bagel, here’s where to look in Nashville, in 2016.

Find a great bagel in Nashville at these spots:

Image title

Proper Bagel 

2011 Belmont Blvd.

Nashville, TN

These newbies on the Nashville bagel scene came here from New York with traditional recipes and approaches and a desire to mix those with “a new school edge” in their new city. The menu offers tried-and-true New York bagel shop favorites, from the scratch-made bagels and bialys to black-and-white cookies. You’ve also got lots of sandwiches, unique flavored butters and straight-outta-Nashville Barista Parlor coffee, among other options.

Image title

Bagel Face Bakery 

700 Main Street

Nashville, TN 

There’s some New York similarity in East Nashville bakery Bagel Face’s bagels too, in that boiled-first crunchy-outside/doughy inside thing. Fun thing those folks do to make their offerings extra fun: regular bagel flavor specials that are anything but run-of-the-mill, from pineapple coconut to carrot cake.

Image title

Star Bagel Cafe 

4504 Murphy Rd

Nashville, TN

The OGs on the Nashville bagel bakery scene, Sylvan Park’s Star Bagel is a must-stop if you’re really particular about healthful ingredients — those folks work hard to focus on fresh, organic, all-natural and local ingredients, and it’s earned Star a devoted following here. It also helps that the bagels, bagelwiches, pizza bagels and such are spot-on — owner Michael Miller did his research (including studying in New York), and it shows.

Image title

Bongo Java East 

107 S 11th St.

Nashville, TN

The coffee’s the initial draw toward Bongo Java, fair enough, but the signature bagel sandwiches at the East Nashville location — which they call bombs — are pretty aptly named, too. The BLT Bomb (exactly what you’d expect) is a tried-and-true favorite for lunch, and the Egg Bomb (scrambled eggs and cheddar cheese, with the option to add bacon or veggie sausage) is a decent sit-in for the classic New York breakfast of egg and cheese on a roll. (They use Bagel Face bagels, too, so…)

Let’s hear your picks: have a favorite spot to grab a bagel in Nashville? Fill me in on Facebook!

Blog author image

TJ Anderson

TJ Anderson is a Nashville Realtor with Benchmark Realty who's helped countless clients both buy a home and sell a home in Nashville, Tennessee. He blogs about Nashville regularly, from Nashville-area....

Latest Blog Posts

How Tile Trends Look To Be Shaking Out For Home Design In 2019

by TJ AndersonThis prediction from Dwell magazine, from late last year, just made its way into my Facebook feed: “Step Aside, Subway Tile — Penny Tile Is the New Classic.” Penny tile,

Read More

Fall Cocktail Recipes From Nashville Mixologists And Restaurants

by TJ AndersonJet back to late summer of 2013, and Imbibe magazine — “the ultimate guide to drinks culture” — was nodding to Nashville’s cocktail scene as “burgeoning.”As we dive into

Read More

Where To Find Replacement Door Knobs For Historic Homes

by TJ AndersonIn newer homes, sure, it’s important to make sure all your details are on point, including door knobs. But with historic homes, those details tend to hold extra weight — period

Read More

5 Reasons Relocating To Williamson County Might Be Right For You

by TJ Anderson16 years ago, when I was first starting out as a Nashville Realtor,  I worked with a lot of post-grads and young couples, buying their first home in neighborhoods close to

Read More